Become a Patron! 


 Dred Scott v. Sandford, 60 U.S. 393 19 How. 393, 15 L.Ed. 691, U.S.Mo.Mar. 06, 1857


As of December 2018, the Dred Scott v Sandford has been negatively referenced  in 29 cases with:



Superseded by Constitutional Amendment

1. Oliver v. Donovan
293 F.Supp. 958 , E.D.N.Y. Order to show cause seeking temporary restraining order enjoining city school superintendent and others from continuing to, inter alia, station police in and around certain schools...
Nov. 26, 1968

2. Keyes v. School Dist. No. 1, Denver, Colo.
609 F.Supp. 1491 , D.Colo. Denver school board moved for an order declaring that school district was a unitary system and terminating jurisdiction of court in desegregation case. The District Court, Matsch,...
June 03, 1985

3. Scott v. C.I.R
1993 WL 335781 , U.S.Tax Ct. This case was assigned to Special Trial Judge Helen A. Buckley pursuant to section 7443A(b)(4) and Rules 180, 181, and 183. The Court agrees with and adopts the opinion of the...
Sep. 07, 1993

4. Scott v. Comptroller of Treasury
659 A.2d 341 , Md.App. TAXES - Income Taxes. Taxpayer's status as African American neither removed her from state or federal citizenship, nor relieved her of her obligations to pay income taxes.
June 05, 1995

5. Rembert v. Monroe Tp. Bd. of Educ.
1997 WL 189318 , D.N.J. This matter appears before the Court on defendant's motion for summary judgment. Because plaintiffs have failed to present a genuine issue of fact for trial, we will grant...
Apr. 14, 1997

6. Hi-Voltage Wire Works, Inc. v. City of San Jose
101 Cal.Rptr.2d 653 , Cal. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS - Preferences and Set-Asides. Attempt to increase participation by minority and women businesses was unconstitutional.
Nov. 30, 2000

7. Barcroft v. County of Fannin
118 S.W.3d 922 , Tex.App.-Texarkana LITIGATION - Dismissal. Plaintiff, suing only in a legal capacity that did not exist, did not have capacity to recover.
Oct. 27, 2003

8. Jones v. Tozzi
2005 WL 1490292 , E.D.Cal. Before the court for decision is a motion to dismiss filed by Defendants Leslie Jensen and John Hollenback. This case, the fourth filed in this court by Plaintiff Melvin Jones...
June 21, 2005

9. In re African-American Slave Descendants Litigation
375 F.Supp.2d 721 , N.D.Ill. LITIGATION - Jurisdiction. Political question doctrine barred adjudication of suit seeking reparations from corporations which profited from slavery.
July 06, 2005

10. U.S. v. Summers
2007 WL 1192198 , E.D.Mich. This matter is before the Court on Defendant Tanisha Summers-El's Notice of Abatement (Motion), filed on February 20, 2007. The Government filed a Response on February 22, 2007....
Apr. 19, 2007

11. Strauss v. Horton
93 Cal.Rptr.3d 591 , Cal. GLBT - Marriage. Measure denying recognition to same-sex marriages was validly enacted as constitutional amendment.
May 26, 2009

12. In re Coats
267 P.3d 324 , Wash. CRIMINAL JUSTICE - Postconviction Relief. Misstatement of maximum possible term did not render judgment and sentence facially invalid.
Nov. 17, 2011

13. State v. Short
851 N.W.2d 474 , Iowa CRIMINAL JUSTICE - Searches and Seizures. In absence of valid search warrant, search of probationer's apartment by law enforcement officers violated Iowa Constitution.
July 18, 2014

14. Toliver v. Artus
2014 WL 4219207 , W.D.N.Y. On January 3, 2013, this Court issued a Decision and Order [# 18] denied the pro se application for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 2254 sought by Samuel R. Toliver...
Aug. 25, 2014

15. Duff v. Holder
2014 WL 5350923 , E.D.N.Y. Petitioner William Duff (“Duff” or “petitioner”) petitions this Court for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 2254, challenging his January 6, 2004 conviction in the...
Oct. 20, 2014

16. Tuaua v. U.S.
788 F.3d 300 , D.C.Cir. IMMIGRATION - Citizenship. Citizenship Clause did not guarantee birthright citizenship to persons born in American Samoa.
June 05, 2015

17. Taylor-Bey v. State
53 N.E.3d 1230 , Ind.App. CRIMINAL JUSTICE - Jurisdiction. Trial court hearing murder case had personal jurisdiction over defendant who claimed he was Moorish American National and not U.S. citizen.
Apr. 28, 2016

18. Brown v. State
64 N.E.3d 1219, Ind.App. CRIMINAL JUSTICE - Counsel. Defendant did not have Sixth Amendment right to “Consuls from the Moorish American Nation” who were not licensed to practice law.
Nov. 22, 2016

19. Miles v. Warden, Marion Correctional Institution
2017 WL 274733, S.D.Ohio This habeas corpus case under 28 U.S.C. 2254 is before the Court on Petitioner’s Objections (ECF No. 25) to the Magistrate Judge’s recommendation that the Petition be dismissed...
Jan. 20, 2017

20. Godfrey v. State
898 N.W.2d 844, Iowa CIVIL RIGHTS - Constitutional Torts. Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of Iowa Constitution were self executing, so as to allow for claim for monetary damages.
June 30, 2017



Not Followed as Dicta


21. U. S. v. Rhodes
27 F.Cas. 785, C.C.D.Ky. Motion in arrest of judgment.



Overruling Recognized


22. State v. Dearmas
841 A.2d 659, R.I. CRIMINAL JUSTICE - Searches and Seizures. Blood seized from unconsenting person is not “property” as term is used in search warrant statute.
Feb. 13, 2004

23. Metaphyzic El-Ectromagnetic Supreme-El v. Director, Dept. of Corrections
2015 WL 1138246, E.D.Va. Metaphyzic El–Ectromagnetic Supreme–El, a Virginia inmate proceeding pro se, submitted a 28 U.S.C. 2254 petition (“ 2254 Petition,” ECF No. 6) challenging his 2013 convictions...
Mar. 03, 2015



Abrogation Recognized


24. Image Carrier Corp. v. Beame
567 F.2d 1197, 2nd Cir. (N.Y.) Nonunion printers brought civil rights action against city officials who enforced city's policy whereby only printers employing union labor and exhibiting union label were...
Dec. 30, 1977

25. Parker v. District of Columbia
478 F.3d 370, D.C.Cir. CIVIL RIGHTS - Right to Bear Arms. District of Columbia's gun control laws were unconstitutional under the Second Amendment.
Mar. 09, 2007

26. Straw Estate of Stevens v. United States
710 Fed.Appx. 881, Fed.Cir. GOVERNMENT - Jurisdiction. Claim of chemical exposure in utero due to father's work as service member sounded in tort, not property, law.
Sep. 11, 2017



Disagreement Recognized


27. U.S. v. Nelson
29 F. 202, D.Alaska Demurrer to Indictment for Selling Distilled Liquors in Sitka, Alaska.

28. Parker v. Judicial Inquiry Commission of the State of Alabama
212 F.Supp.3d 1171, M.D.Ala. JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATION - Discipline. Judicial ethics investigation was ongoing state judicial proceeding for purposes of Younger abstention.
Sep. 29, 2016





29. United States v. Olea
2016 WL 8730167, D.Mass. Defendant Dagoberto Olea (“Olea” or “the defendant”) has moved to dismiss Count One of a superseding indictment (“the Indictment”) charging him with conspiring to distribute and to...
Aug. 12, 2016